Generative

The Changing Landscape is Why Our Work Matters

A gravel bike route I have ridden over the years paralleled the United States-Mexico border. The border was a barbed-wire fence, and it was hard to distinguish unless one got within a few feet. On a ride this month, the border is now demarcated by a thirty-foot fence.

It would be easy to assume that this rural tract of land would remain relatively unchanged, as it has for decades. The wall’s construction has altered the landscape and several variables, including how the border is monitored and secured, migration of wildlife, view corridors from border-adjacent ranching communities, short-term economic impact of a federal construction project, improvement of dirt roads to support construction vehicles, increase in visitors, more media attention, among other changes.

When we plan, we often defer to the sense that things will stay the same unless we feel the impact of change in the current moment. One argument for asking generative questions is that they let us consider alternate possibilities without the tension of finding the answers: What else might be true? Who could be affected? What would change if this constraint disappeared? What might we be missing? Considering alternate realities offers a pathway to avoid adopting a ‘fixed mindset.’ Just because you purchased the Lego set that contains the pieces to construct the Magic Kingdom does not mean you are restricted to just one outcome or version.

How might we remember that the work we do matters, and that it is not easy because the conditions are constantly changing?

Pushing Forward and Scrubbing Speed

If we endeavor to keep our cause in perpetual motion, we might miss the opportunity to address deferred maintenance. Sailors who circumnavigate the globe look for opportunities to lift their boats above the water line to clean the hull and handle other necessary maintenance. To enhance the performance and efficiency of the boat’s movement through the water, the return on investment of a clean hull versus the time lost in port is a formidable decision.

How might we take the same mindset with our enterprises? How might we take time for a generative conversation? How might we address opportunities to improve our governance? How might we reflect upon or update our strategic plan? How might we update our board recruitment roster? How might we test our organizational assumptions?

What is the return on investment if we commit to any of the items mentioned above? What would a transformative moment of pause do for the future journey?

Organized

Utilities laid out within a coherent system make sense. We want items fundamental to our operations to be accessible, functional, and safe. Generative ideas are not created or built upon in the same mindset. We might need to get ourselves lost in the wilderness before understanding the terrain we occupy. Discerning our work might guide us between a functional approach or inhabiting a liminal state of mind.

Inclusions

When we hold a precious stone up to an intense light, it reveals any inclusions and blemishes. We might be utilizing the stone for a purpose that does not require a high grade, or we may intend to make the stone the centerpiece of our work, which would benefit from fewer visible inclusions.

What light do we deploy to explore our organization’s inner workings? Do we have a culture of curiosity that is open to examining our enterprise’s status? Does a generative conversation make us stronger as a team or does it reveal fault lines that create more friction?

Other Questions (Part Two)

It is probably quickly forgotten if we bring a stuffed animal to a hockey game and throw it onto the ice after the home team scores. However, if the home team holds a toy drive and thousands of stuffed animals are thrown onto the ice after the first goal, it is remarkable. Questions are similar; one rouge question might get a quick response, but a cascade of intentional questions can steer an enterprise’s future strategy.

What questions must you answer before you can ask another question?

Do you need to agree that contributed income is a vital source of revenue for your venture? Once established that contributed income is a priority, you can commence with questions about how your cause engages potential supporters in meaningful conversations about their philanthropy? The sub-questions have little value if we have not answered the essential question.

Changing Topography

The power of generative conversation is similar to playing in a sandbox. We can build, alter, and discard ideas without worrying about the constraints of reality. Like the Topography Sandbox, we can quickly alter the terrain and consider new possibilities. How might we make room for generative conversation in our next meeting?